This new business analytics case study challenges readers to help a companys sustainability coordinator choose her first high-profile project, based on both qualitative and quantitative inputs, including alignment with the companys mission. Readers will consider three alternatives with significantly different financial and timing implications and decision-making criteria. Crystallizing realistic analytical challenges faced by companies in many industries, this case study covers the entire decision-making process, providing opportunities to perform analyses, interpret output, and recommend optimal actions. Author: Robert P. Sroufe and Marie Fechik-Kirk, Duquesne University.